Es war einmal in Amerika

Es war einmal in Amerika ist ein Film mit einer uneinheitlichen Laune, der nicht komplex ist. Ich fand ihn aber trotzdem fesselnd. Immer, wenn ich mich an Morricones Hauptmotiv erinnere, wird mir warm ums Herz und ich denke an die Silhouetten vom grauen Robert De Niro, von der schönen jungen Jennifer Connelly und der großen Brooklyn-Brücke. Es war einmal in Amerika ist ein harter sowie zarter, aber vor allem ein schön poetischer Film, der langsam in Ihren Gedanken zergehen und jeden Tag wichtiger sein wird. (04.07.2004)

I would love to write about this dream project of Sergio Leone, to which he devoted many years of his life, that I was so absorbed at the beginning and at the end I didn't want to go back to reality. Unfortunately, I can only say that about the first half, especially the period of Noodles's childhood, which was beautifully and sensitively filmed. The rest, however... First of all, the fact that Leone’s dream epic doesn't bore at all and doesn't feel draggy despite its nearly four-hour runtime is only due to his directorial mastery. Unfortunately, it falters a bit on the screenwriting front. It's as if Leone took too big a bite, or as betelgeuse rightly points out here, as if he had made a series, but lost a few episodes and artfully glued the rest together. Some of the characters are underdeveloped, and at times it's hard to trust the motives behind their actions. For example, the character of Joe Pesci, promisingly sharp, there’s a shot of him by a hospital elevator as if the director was suggesting "Watch out, he's still here!", but suddenly he disappears somewhere and incomprehensibly does not appear in the film anymore. I didn't believe James Woods for a second at the very end, nor did I believe his intended action, and I found the whole point about him quite implausible. However, what must definitely be appreciated is the absolutely precise, to the smallest detail elaborate design, the visual depiction of three different stages of the 20th century. Leone's perfectionism went so far that even for one short shot he was willing to "coach" hundreds of extras, believably period-styled and moving in a perfect set. Even the aged De Niro looked excellent, though perhaps it’s a little puzzling that the filmmakers did not bother too much with the character of Deborah, whose 35-year difference was not noticeable and as an almost 60-year-old woman she still looked like a 20-year-old girl. All in all, I am satisfied, but I can safely say that Once Upon a Time in the West remains unsurpassed. (20.09.2004)

A breathtaking colossus of a film. Like in Once Upon a Time in the West, the music plays a hugely important part, it builds the atmosphere of each era and highlights the emotional scenes, bringing the viewer right into the film (or the film into the viewer). An incredible experience. (20.02.2009)

I could bend over backward, and I still probably wouldn't find any mistakes in Once Upon a Time in America. For almost four hours, Sergio Leone tells us what it means to have a friendship beyond the grave. With an almost unhealthy precision, it closely observes the three-generational clash of men who had no other choice but to do what they did since their youth. Building an empire with all its pleasures and problems. Love, hate, virtue, mistakes, and that friendship... All this in a mesmerizing audiovisual setting. Hypnotic music by Ennio Morricone with a beautifully catchy melody. Long and slow camera "walks." A brilliant shot focuses on a street where a group of boys is crossing, with the iconic Brooklyn Bridge towering in the background, nestled between two buildings. Perfection. Which time period is the best? That's a tough question. Youth, with all its worries, abounds with that childlike look of boys whom the street has forced to grow up all too soon. The central and longest part depicts their built empire during its peak prosperity until the final stage, where the inevitable reckoning of their past actions takes center stage. Leone transitions between these periods subtly and unobtrusively, but always the contrast of period diversity is incredibly beautiful. I have a warm feeling in my heart that I sacrificed four hours for something so spectacular and hard to describe. Master, from the bottom of my heart, thank you... (15.02.2005)

Eine langwierige Mafia-Macho-Saga. Je ausdrucksloser die Figuren und je platter die Dialoge sind, desto älter wird der Film. Leones Genialität blitzt hier natürlich ab und zu auf, alles in allem ist es aber wie mit Morricones Musik. Sie ist ziemlich wirkungsvoll, klingt aber zu vertraut und die Panflöte hat beinahe auch den phänomenalen Film Picknick am Valentinstag kaputtgemacht. Dieses Festival der rührseligen Blicke von menschlichen Ausrufezeichen wird zu einem nostalgischen Museumsexponat der Filmwelt, das zum Glück in die Welt von Gestern gehört. (02.01.2023)

There are some pictures for which even the maximum number of stars is too constricting. And Leone’s most personal work is just that type of movie. But it is hard to give it an adequate rating since even the four-hour version eventually released years later is still too short to be able to reveal all of the storylines that Sergio Leone had filmed. The result is that we are left with a lot of begun, but unfinished storylines (Frankie Joe, Pesci and Fat Moe, to name just a few). They should release the originally intended six-hour version. This way we are left with incredibly strong historical frescos that Leone guides extremely sensitively through three time periods, supported by Morricone’s music, superb actors, amazing technical effects and outstanding production design. The best part of this picture is the first third. This is where Leone’s storytelling is at its best and I dare say that this part is the very best thing that Leone created (the word “filmed" simply isn’t enough in this case) during his long career. (14.01.2007)

Although many comments try to do it, Leone's gems with the poetic "Once upon a Time" in the title are completely incomparable. In his masterpiece, the Master has included almost every genre. I found classic crime schemes, tough gangster action, heart-wrenching drama, and despite its harshness, also a strong and sincere romance, all with a subtle veil of social criticism. When watching the director's cut, I cannot imagine a single scene that I could miss. I am listing the individual aspects here, but the power of this monument cannot be described with words. (13.04.2006)

Once Upon a Time in America was a film that Sergio Leone had been preparing for many years and was supposed to be the culmination of his work. In reality, it turned out to be a major disaster and probably shortened Leone's life by a few years. Finding a producer was already extremely difficult because, with Leone's well-known meticulousness, the costs were dangerously high. Moreover, the film was incredibly long, especially for the standards of the early 80s. The producer simply couldn't imagine that a four-hour epic would be acceptable to the audience, and since in the United States the producer is practically the owner of the film, he dealt with it in his own way. He cut it in half and released this butchered version in movie theaters. Because Leone's story takes place in multiple time frames, the crude interventions resulted in a debacle that the critics tore apart and the audience jeered. The film became one of the worst flops of the decade and, considering the high costs, it meant the actual end of Leone's directing career. He never experienced rehabilitation until his death, which came six years later with the release of the original director's cut. Yes, it is very long, but at the same time, it is very captivating, professionally shot, and grandiose. Over time, film fans and professional critics have evaluated Leone's film as one of the most significant in American cinema. For many actors, it was the pinnacle of their film careers, although in some cases, admittedly, somewhat premature (Elizabeth McGovern). Overall impression: 90%. (08.01.2008)

What Sergio Leone delivers here is almost perfect. Amazing atmosphere and storytelling, and flawless performances. The brilliant script and its three timelines are a testament to genius. Leone was originally meant to direct The Godfather, but he knew why to wait. This film is better. (17.05.2004)

Sergio Leone breathtaking again. I don't know if it’s true that the script took 12 years to develop, but looking at the final quality and refinement of this film, I could easily believe it. The 220 minutes run like a well-oiled machine, the actors perform like clockwork, and Ennio Morricone contributes another unforgettable soundtrack. All this accompanied by a monumental story that manages to grip the viewer so tightly that there is no chance of release before the closing credits. Leone weaves the three storylines very nicely, giving the viewer space to become as attached to the characters as possible and to take in the atmosphere of the prohibition era in which much of the action takes place. But it’s only at the very end that we realize how beautifully all of that has worked all along, and what a wonderfully compelling and thoughtful work we have just had the privilege of seeing. And that’s where I see the greatest magic of Once Upon a Time in America. (31.07.2012)

[251 minute extended] Leaving aside the scale of the work and the incredible set and camera work, there remains a bit of a taste on the palate that Leone has sold out his previous revisionist approach to film genres here for a purely academic perspective, which is most evident in his work with the characters, which isn't very well developed due to the fact that they aren't given as much space as the sets. With de Niro's endless silent and melancholic glances at the recollection of his mafia youth, after a while I just saw... well, de Niro staring. And apart from that the story, namely building a giant sophisticated mafia saga on a restrained, yet actually stupid gangster, seems good to me. The heretic in me can almost imagine a good 140-minute cut of that film, except there would be cutting not of scenes but within scenes. (18.07.2021)

Sergio Leone did not disappoint in any way and once again proved that film is everything to him and that he is able to capture an image and scene in such a way that almost no one else can. His principles from Western movies work brilliantly in an American mafia film, where there are absolutely captivating scenes supported by great performances. However, "Once Upon a Time in the West" does not surpass it in my case. (21.12.2015)