Mary & Max oder Schrumpfen Schafe wenn es regnet?

Anekdotischer und dauerschwarzer morbider Kern des Harvie Krumpets hat sich bis zu einem abendfüllenden Format ausgedehnt und ist leicht mit Infantilität verdünnt worden. Leider ist es Elliot nicht gelungen die Anzeichen von Selbstzweck, Billigkeit und gestrecktem Brei zu vermeiden, obwohl selbst diesmal die Atmosphäre und die Charaktere leicht unter die Haut gehen. Mary & Max oder Schrumpfen Schafe wenn es regnet? gehören zu den seltsamsten Zeichentrickfilmen, die Sie jemals zu gesicht bekommen werden. Die künstlerischen Aspekte stärken lediglich noch die Deformität und Psychose der Hauptfiguren. Umso schöner ist es jedoch sodann zu sehen, wie der Film reine und positive Emotionen hervorruft. Schade nur um die gelegentlichen Wiederholungen sowie die übermäßige Beredsamkeit. (14.08.2009)

Die wunderbare Geschichte einer starken Freundschaft zwischen zwei Ausgestoßenen der Gesellschaft, Max und Mary, ist eine der süßesten Kirschen auf dem Obstkuchen der Animation. Der fesselnde und direkte Erzählstil, die rasante Handlung und die großartige Musikauswahl haben sich neben der starken Geschichte in mein Gedächtnis eingebrannt. Kurzum, ein Meisterwerk der Filmkunst, das mich gleichzeitig zum Lachen gebracht, bewegt und erstaunt hat - eine starke Kombination für einen Film, der anderthalb Stunden lang ist. (27.02.2011)

I believe that if an un-loquacious version of this existed, it would work equally as well as the “silencing" of Blade Runner. However, this way it is an outstanding movie that is utterly wrecked by overuse of the narrator. Even though quite soon there is no longer any reason for his existence, he drivels gloomily on and on. This absolutely ruins the atmosphere which is given a chance to pervade only in a few rare moments when at last there’s silence. And at those moments I would willingly award both Mary and Max five stars. But then the narrator opens the flood gates again and lets flow his prattle about nothing and the atmosphere is gone. Oh dear. (07.11.2009)

There is no denying that this distinctive movie has an idea that immediately propels it among the top animated works to date. To see the filth and stench of modern society depicted in such a subtle way in a film (and the filmmakers went back 30 years for good measure) is not something a more mature viewer is used to, even in the presence of David Lynch or Lance Von Trier, let alone in a story that is primarily intended for a younger audience. And here is the only problem. Although this is an endlessly thought-provoking, truthful and original film that combines a sometimes depressing atmosphere with humorous detachment in perhaps the best possible way, its emotional impact is so contrived and violent at times that I too often just shook my head in disbelief at all the bugs, dead birds and fish, the endless funerals and the enormous weirdness of the two main characters. But the filmmakers communicate very clearly what they want to say, which is why my sympathies remain on the side of the film. (02.02.2014)

In the minds of the overwhelming majority of viewers, the notion still persists that animated films are primarily for children and at most can have a cross-over appeal as a family entertainment for children's company. Adam Elliot's work defies this established classification, and his film Mary and Max is anything but a film intended for child audiences. It is a psychological drama that portrays the formation of friendship between two completely different individuals, who are only connected by their outsider status. A little girl from Australia, suffering from unwanted child syndrome, growing up in a family that can hardly be considered functional, and a solitary obese Jew suffering from a mental illness, both long for friendship and find it through letters addressed to a distant continent. The film sensitively and non-aggressively describes the emergence of an emotional bond and the ups and downs of their relationship. It is a very exclusive intimate film, intended more for contemplation than entertainment. At the same time, it is one of the peaks of contemporary animated film and evidence that animated cinema has fully emancipated itself on par with live-action films. In terms of emotions, Elliot excels at working with the natures of his characters and exposes them to a multitude of problems they must face. The number of mishaps concentrated in their lives would be enough for the entire staff of a sought-after psychiatrist or psychologist within a few days. Yet, Mary and Max manage to approach life with humor and contemplate, for example, whether a taxi driver who reverses owes money to the customer or vice versa. The visual aspect didn't completely capture my heart, but in terms of script and direction quality, the film deserves the best possible rating. Overall impression: 85%. (02.05.2010)