Die Dolmetscherin

Eine gut gespielte akademische Langeweile. Das emotionale Brodeln zwischen den Hauptfiguren wird durch die politische Ebene gestört, die an sich auch nicht überzeugend ist. Und daraus konnte nichts Besonderes werden. Schade. (24.06.2005)

Ein funktionierender Thriller mit einem sehr guten Hauptdarstellerpaar. Nicoles Charakter wurde durch das interessante Drehbuch, ihre Emotionen und ihr Styling in Blautönen so gut herausgearbeitet, dass es kaum zu glauben ist, dass sie eine weiße Afrikanerin repräsentiert. Madame Australia hat fürwahr ein sehr breites Register. (02.07.2016)

The interpreter plays out on the well-worn paths of Sydney Pollack's thrillers and to some extent imitates the framework of his Three Days of the Condor. However, unlike that film, it is not as precise, and the plot of the political conspiracy and the budding love affair between the main heroine and the investigator is somewhat forced. Sean Penn stands very high in my opinion as an actor, but his role as a secret service agent is perhaps the first one I did not believe in, even though I do not claim that he gives a weak performance. It's just that his interpretation is somewhat indigestible to me. I don't think secret service agents should be bruisers and nerveless people, but if my colleague showed such strong emotions, I would probably be afraid that he would not pass the psychological tests and he would unsettle me somewhat. Nicole Kidman's performance is a decent standard, but let's be honest, it would be much fairer to cast a black girl in the role given the subject matter and plot. I didn't believe in her as a partisan either, thankfully it was just the one photograph. Pollack has an uneven pace and a somewhat forced ending, but the plot with a twist is compelling and quite original, and the 20 minutes framed by the interpreter's meeting with the opposition leader and the subsequent bus assassination are absolutely precise. If the film maintained such an atmosphere and dynamism throughout, it would be worth five stars. Overall impression: 65%. I was disappointed with the use or rather non-use of Catherine Keener, who is an excellent actress, and she simply did not deserve to play such an unnecessary character... (29.03.2010)

Under different circumstances, this would be an absolutely solid thriller that kills the good premise by actually taking place in Nicole Kidmanʼs head and everyone else looks as if they were some extras. At the same time, you keep hoping that the movie will not be futile and will at least offer a solid set. But after watching, you realize that wasn’t really the case. Rather it will seem to you that the whole story actually selfishly took place on the sofa in Nicoleʼs flat. However, it deserves the fourth star for the final scene, which keeps you on tenterhooks, and mainly for Sean Penn. That’s mainly thanks to the finale which showed once again how great and honest actor he is. (24.12.2016)

I like Sydney Pollack. His pleasantly restrained direction, without quick cuts and wannabe cool shots (hello Tony Scott), lets the skill of the actors shine through (hello Clint Eastwood), but here he had a weaker moment. For a thriller it lacks suspense, as a political drama it's unconvincing and too slippery on the surface, and the melodramatic level is brought down by the chemistry between the two main protagonists, which has the sparkle of a burnt down Christmas light. The result is an unclear bit of tedium with one big logical lapse at the end. Still, a certain three stars, I quite like these old-fashioned thrillers, without fancy frills. (10.12.2005)