You Don't Know Jack

Im Gegensatz zu vielen anderen Usern behaupte ich nicht, dass Jack Kevorkian Al Pacinos beste Rolle ist. Ich schließe mich aber gern der Meinung an, dass er sie perfekt und atemberaubend dargestellt hat. Der Film, der mehr als zwei Stunden dauert, ist vor allem dank ihm fesselnd (er spielt den Arzt nicht, er ist der Arzt – so, wie wir es bei ihm gewohnt sind). Es wäre aber ein Fehler, Barry Levinson und die hervorragenden Schauspieler*innen in den Nebenrollen zu vergessen – die bis zur Unkenntlichkeit veränderte Susan Sarandon, den wie immer sympathischen John Goodman oder Danny Huston mit einer wirklich blöden Frisur. Die Sterbehilfe ist immer noch ein heikles Thema (ich verstehe nicht, warum). Ich war froh, dass es von den Filmemachern so wie der Tod von Dr. Kevorkian behandelt wurde – mit Sensibilität und Würde. Danke HBO, dass du diesen Film gedreht hast. (20.02.2011)

I’m just writing an assignment about euthanasia, but I stopped writing until I had the chance to watch You Don’t Know Jack. Of course, I also read some books about it, but I said to myself that Pacino might make me a little more enthusiastic about this topic and make the essay better. And I wasn’t wrong, Kevorkian is his best role for the last few years and it’s a pleasure to see him act with such enthusiasm. But I certainly mustn’t forget about John Goodman who complements Al perfectly and some scenes make this almost a snappy-lined buddy movie. Barry Levinson pulls some director’s aces from his sleeve, the story gracefully depicts all the years of Kevorkian’s struggle against the system. I was afraid that, being a TV movie, it might lose some of its punch, but in fact it’s the other way around. This is a personal drama that people should watch at home and have time to think about it in peace without someone crunching on popcorn in the seat behind him. This is a picture about respect for human life and about the opportunity to choose. If those aren’t fundamental themes, I don’t know what is. Way to go, Jack! (15.07.2010)

A nice film about a strong topic with a (let’s not exaggerate) very good performance by Al Pacino. But a TV film is still a TV film. What irritated me personally was that Kevorkian’s opposition is portrayed only with a bunch of religious fanatics and an arrogant lawyer. Even though I’m in favour of euthanasia, I’ve met people who support the opposing view and they were able to argue very well. I really missed that kind of opposition in You Don't Know Jack, and compared to other users, I will keep my feet on the ground. 7/10 (12.09.2010)